So, about two weeks ago,
handyhunter put up this test-
From theangryblackwoman.com: The Bechdel Test and Race in Popular Fiction
1. It has to have two POC in it.
2. Who talk to each other.
3. About something other than a white person.
Clearly, it is taken from the Bechdel Test that relates to Gender:
1. It has to have two women in it.
2. Who talk to each other.
3. About something other than a man.
The Angry Black Woman (and
handyhunter) then proceeded to talk about various fandoms and do a basic "measure" of them. I was so fascinated by this idea that I've decided to copy it and apply both tests to my fandoms, just to see what there is to see.
I'm increasingly curious as to what fandoms actually pass these tests, especially given all of the recent commentary about
Supernatural and
Glee, which are both shows that I enjoy, but neither show generally inspires me to fic.
Anyway, onto the tests. These are all shows that I watch regularly. I really want to do this for other forms of fandom, too – comics, manga/anime, but I don't have time at the moment. I will come back to it though.
( Shows )Now, having gone through my own, completely unscientific analysis of these shows, I am curious as to why some of them receive a higher level of dispensation than others. I realize that my tastes are sort of varied, and there tends to be a bit of something in most categories in this list, but there is definitely a bewize-bias in everything on this list. This is the content of *my* tivo.
(If you read all that, I'd love to hear your comments on these shows, or comments on the shows that you watch. And I'd love to know why some shows engender more negative comments on race and gender issues than other shows that I don't watch.)
For example, and off the top of my head, I've heard
Torchwood criticized for gender issues, but not race issues. I've rarely heard
Doctor Who criticized for either. Both have room for improvement, from what I can see.
Leverage seems to often be praised for having a character of color in the limelight, while from what I can see, it doesn't pass the Bechdel test in terms of race, when
Dollhouse, which stirs nothing but fan controversy, does pass the test.
I realize that a lot of the problems can come about from exactly how the cast is portrayed (
Dollhouse), or that problems can be soothed by having a minority character appear a central part of the cast (
Psych, Leverage), but like I said – this is just a starting place for thinking.
And as always, there is tons of room for disagreement. Feel free to point out anything that I missed, please.